PersonalFoul Rookie Rankings – November 14, 2015

Just a month into the season, the 2015 Draft Class begun settling into their roles as franchise cornerstones. While some have had an easy transition into the professional game, others have struggled out of the gate. Here are our early rookie rankings so far:



On the most talented team among his counterparts, Towns has shown steady flashes of his future brilliance. Already an above-average defender, Towns’ has been most surprising on the offensive side of the ball– particularly considering he shares the offensive load with Andrew Wiggins and Zack Lavine. Shooting nearly 50% from the field, the #1 pick has shown a diverse inside game, well ahead of his age. He also benefits from the tutelage of Kevin Garnett, an invaluable mentor early in his career and the playmaking ability of Rubio. Clearly in the best position to succeed, Towns will be a 20/10 player for years to come– but many will be surprised by how quickly he reaches that point.



Okafor has been giving Sixers fans plenty of reason to “trust the system”. On a team with no scoring options, Okafor has taken the responsibility of being the primary offensive catalyst, with impressive albeit inefficient results. Averaging just under 20 points a game, he has lived up to the hype of being the most NBA-ready player available in the draft, taking advantage of smaller defenders. However, he as also had trouble dealing with the league’s more prominent big-men. Okafor needs more polish to his game– a decent ball-handling guard could help– but there is no reason to think he will not be among the 2 or 3 best Centers in the game for years to come.


Porzingis has shown the most potential out of all the lottery picks thus far. Although his shot is not yet falling, he has proven to be an aggressive rebounder and a better than advertised defender. His body- a critique of his in the draft– has also held up quite well against other NBA big men, with his length in particular being an advantage. Unlike his previous 2 counterparts, Kirstaps does not have the luxury of having the offense run through him just yet– at least not while Carmelo is still a Knick- but his game is versatile enough to make an impact on the game. He will be a player that will get better as the year goes on– especially if he can get out of his shooting slump.


Mudiay has gone through the ups and downs of the NBA season, but is fortunate to be in a situation where his team allows him to play through his mistakes. A confident player, Mudiay has accepted the role of volume scorer with varying degrees of success. The efficiency is not where it should be, but he has shown flashes of being a prominent offensive option. His athleticism is also as advertised, and many have been pleasantly surprised with his play-making abilities. He is an incomplete picture at this point– but NBA experience will round out his rough edges.


Where Mudiay has gone through ups and downs, Russell’s prospects have been dwelling closer to the basement. Russell has many different things going against him. On one hand, he plays in a system that does not take advantage of his strengths, running a relatively stagnant offense opposed to his up-tempo tendencies. Unlike his counterparts, he averages the least amount of minutes, stunting his progression, and perhaps most importantly, plays aside less than complementary players in Jordan Clarkson and Kobe Bryant. Mired in a shooting slump, his coach shows little confidence in him. That being said, there have been flashes of potential– although faint. A drastic personnel change will have to be made in order to truly unlock his skills, but the prospects are rather bleak. In my opinion, there is still very much a wait and see approach to his game at this point– but it speaks to his talent that among his obvious issues, he still comes off as a competent player.


Agree? Disagree? Sound off below!


2 thoughts on “PersonalFoul Rookie Rankings – November 14, 2015

  1. Jahlil should be #1, Towns should be 2. KP is fine. The last 2 neither one of them should be on here before Justise Winslow. He is clearly better than both. He can actually be interchangeable with 2 and 3 to be honest. His play has been that good so far

    Liked by 1 person

    • I like Winslow’s game, but I would put him up only as high as 5. Mudiay is practically the offensive focal point on his team, so I give him leeway for his mistakes whereas Winslow is a complementary piece thus far behind Whiteside, Wade, Bosh. No knock on him though; he was a steal at where they got him and you can certainly make an argument he has made a bigger impact than Russell thus far.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s